You did the responsible thing and went to the dentist. You got a new crown in Chicago, but now you’re living with a tooth that doesn’t feel right. Maybe it sits too high when you bite down, it’s a shade off from the teeth next to it, or it popped off after a few months. Maybe it just never felt like it belonged in your mouth.
You’re frustrated, and you’re not sure what to do next. Do you go back to the same dentist? Do you find someone new, or do you just live with it?
Here’s what we want you to know at North Dental Professionals in Chicago. You don’t have to accept a crown that feels wrong. Fixing it doesn’t mean starting from scratch with a stranger who doesn’t understand what went wrong the first time either.
Dr. Paul Chaiken has been practicing dentistry for more than 40 years. He’s seen every kind of failed crown, every kind of unhappy patient, and every kind of “this doesn’t feel right” complaint. He’s also fixed a lot of them. Here’s why crowns fail, and how we approach the fix.

Why Crowns Fail: It’s Usually Not Your Fault
When a crown doesn’t work out, patients often blame themselves. They think they chewed on something they shouldn’t have, didn’t brush well enough, or should have known better.
Most of the time, that’s not the case. Crown failures usually come down to a handful of causes, and most of them are clinical, not behavioral. For example:
- The bite wasn’t adjusted properly. This is the most common cause. A crown that sits slightly too high or contacts at the wrong angle can cause discomfort, uneven wear, and eventual failure. The patient feels it immediately, but sometimes the dentist doesn’t catch it because the adjustment wasn’t thorough enough.
- The margins weren’t sealed. The margin is where the crown meets the tooth at the gumline. If that seal isn’t tight, bacteria can get underneath, causing decay and eventual crown failure.
- The shade or shape was off. This is a cosmetic failure rather than a functional one, but it matters just as much to the patient. A crown that doesn’t match the surrounding teeth is noticeable, especially on a front tooth.
- The cement failed. Over time, the cement that holds the crown in place can break down, especially if the crown is under excessive force from grinding or a misaligned bite.
- The tooth underneath wasn’t healthy enough. If the tooth had decay or a crack that wasn’t fully addressed before placing the crown, the crown won’t fix the underlying problem.
- The crown was rushed. Some practices operate on high volume and low time per patient. When a crown is placed quickly without careful attention to fit, bite, and esthetics, problems show up later.
Dr. Chaiken’s approach is the opposite of rushed. He’s built his reputation on meticulous work, and he’s been recognized for it. He holds fellowships from the American College of Dentists and the Academy of General Dentistry, and he’s an assistant clinical professor at Northwestern University School of Medicine. That’s not a marketing claim. It reflects how he practices.
What a Second Opinion Actually Looks Like
If your crown is bothering you, the first step is a proper evaluation. Not a quick glance. A real assessment of what’s happening.
At North Dental Professionals, Dr. Chaiken starts by listening. What feels wrong? When did you first notice it? Does it hurt when you bite? Does it feel high, loose, or just “off”? Has it come off before?
Then he examines the crown, the tooth underneath, and the bite. He uses digital X-rays and intraoral cameras to see what’s happening beneath the surface. He checks the margins, the fit, and the contact points. Dr. Chaiken looks at how the crown meets the opposing teeth and whether the bite is balanced.
This is where the diagnostic technology matters. Dr. Chaiken uses AI-assisted radiological analysis to catch what a standard X-ray might miss, and intraoral cameras to show patients exactly what he’s seeing. The goal isn’t just to diagnose the problem. It’s to show you what’s happening so you understand why it feels wrong and what needs to change.
The Fix Depends on the Problem
No single solution fits every failed crown. The right fix depends on what went wrong.
- If the bite is off, the crown may be adjustable. A small amount of reshaping can bring it into balance, and the discomfort can resolve quickly. This is often the simplest fix.
- If the margins are compromised, you may need to remove and reseat the crown, or replace it entirely. If decay has formed underneath, that needs to be treated first.
- If the shade or shape is off, you may need a new crown. Dr. Chaiken designs crowns to match the surrounding teeth in color, shape, and translucency. A natural-looking crown is the standard, not a bonus.
- If the tooth underneath is the problem, the treatment plan may involve a root canal, a new buildup, or a different restoration. Dr. Chaiken has advanced training in root canal therapy, so he can address the underlying issue in-house rather than referring you out.
- If the crown is loose but not damaged, we may be able to re-cement it. We clean the tooth and crown, refresh the cement, and reseat the crown with careful attention to the bite.
In many cases, the fix is less involved than patients expect. In some cases, it’s a full replacement. Either way, you’ll leave with a clear plan and a clear cost estimate before anything is done.
Why Experience Matters for a Second Opinion
Fixing someone else’s work is different from doing it the first time. It requires a diagnostic eye that’s seen many failures and knows what to look for.
Dr. Chaiken has been practicing since 1984. He’s seen crowns placed by every kind of dentist, in every kind of office, with every kind of outcome. He’s also served on clinical advisory boards for dental research publications and as a medical consultant to the American Medical Association. Dr. Chaiken is a published author and a clinical professor. His perspective on a failed crown isn’t just clinical. It’s informed by decades of watching what works and what doesn’t.
Dr. Angel Frazier, who also practices at North Dental Professionals, brings complementary expertise. She has a special interest in cosmetic dentistry and oral surgery, and she’s completed extensive advanced training in implant dentistry. If the failed crown is part of a larger issue involving the tooth’s structure or the surrounding teeth, she can evaluate whether a different approach might be the better long-term solution.
Together, they can view a failed crown from multiple angles and recommend the fix that makes sense long term, not just the quickest patch.
What Patients in Chicago Should Know
If you’re in Edison Park, Norwood Park, Jefferson Park, Park Ridge, Niles, or anywhere on Chicago’s northwest side, you have options for a second opinion. Here’s what to look for:
- A dentist who listens first. If the first thing you hear is a sales pitch for a new crown, that’s a red flag. A good second opinion starts with a conversation and a real evaluation.
- A dentist who shows you what they see. Uses digital X-rays and intraoral cameras to explain the problem, not just to diagnose it. You should understand why your crown feels wrong before you agree to a fix.
- A dentist who explains the options. Sometimes the fix is a small adjustment. Sometimes it’s a replacement. A good dentist will explain the range of options and the trade-offs.
- A dentist who doesn’t rush. A second opinion takes time. If the visit feels rushed, that’s a sign the practice isn’t set up for careful work.
Dr. Chaiken’s practice is built around careful work. He’s not a high-volume dentist, and he’s not trying to see as many patients as possible in a day. He takes the time to get it right, which is why patients come to him for second opinions.
What to Ask Before You Agree to a Fix
If you’re considering a second opinion or a fix, ask a few questions:
- What exactly is wrong with the crown? The answer should be specific, not general.
- Can I see the imaging? A good dentist will show you what they’re seeing.
- What are the options, and what are the trade-offs? There’s usually more than one way to fix a problem. Ask about all of them.
- How long will the fix last? A quick patch may not last as long as a full replacement. Ask about the expected lifespan.
- What’s the cost, and does insurance cover any of it? Ask for a clear estimate before treatment begins.
At North Dental Professionals, we accept most dental insurance, offer CareCredit financing, and have a dental savings plan for patients without insurance. We’ll walk you through the cost before we do anything.
You Don’t Have to Live With a Bad Crown
You don’t have to accept a crown that feels wrong. It’s usually a problem we can diagnose and fix, often more simply than you’d expect.
If you’re in Chicago and you’re unhappy with a crown, call North Dental Professionals at 708-274-4192 or request an appointment online. Our Chicago office is in the Edison Park area on the northwest side, and we serve patients from Norwood Park, Jefferson Park, Park Ridge, Niles, and the surrounding neighborhoods.
Let us help you get the result you were promised!
